Are we barking up the right tree? Evaluating a comparative approach to personality
Publication Type: |
Journal Article |
Year of Publication: |
2002 |
Authors: |
Samuel D. Gosling, Simine Vazire |
Publication/Journal: |
Journal of Research in Personality |
Keywords: |
animal personality, behavioral syndromes, behavioural syndromes, person-situation debate, temperament |
Abstract:
Animal studies can enrich the field of human personality psychology by addressing questions that are difficult or impossible to address with human studies alone. However, the benefits of a comparative approach to personality cannot be reaped until the tenability of the personality construct has been established in animals. Using criteria established in the wake of the person–situation debate (Kenrick & Funder, 1988), the authors evaluate the status of personality traits in animals. The animal literature provides strong evidence that personality does exist in animals. That is, personality ratings of animals: (a) show strong levels of interobserver agreement, (b) show evidence of validity in terms of predicting behaviors and real-world outcomes, and (c) do not merely reflect the implicit theories of observers projected onto animals. Although much work remains to be done, the preliminary groundwork has been laid for a comparative approach to personality.